Plasma wayland vs x11. There are still compatibility issues.
Plasma wayland vs x11 A few days ago I upgraded my system from Fedora 39 (which is EOL since November this year) to Fedora 41. Then I'll switch back to X11. . No hate on Wayland, but pleading for people to stop using it is an uphill battle KDE Plasma should use X11 according to Tested's video. Comparing xorg vs wayland, there are key differences. 57. a wayland compositor does a lot more than an x11 wm. To force-enable Wayland, override these rules by creating the following symlink: Installing ktorrent wants to remove kwin-x11 and plasma-workspace-x11???? Phoronix: KDE Plasma 6. Don't be a dick. Lack of native Wayland support in apps generally. Given some time and more maturity, there will be fewer tradeoffs. Woohoo! Logging in automatically with X11. i comment out most of the settings in i3/config, it's up to you what you want to use. In my current build I got x11 kde, Wayland x11, and hyprland. Wayland on Plasma 6 is there from the beginning, the default and what the developers are also using during development. So i will stick to good old X11 in the foreseeable future. Exactly. Reply reply Which is better for me, x11 or wayland? Hard to say. Wayland or xORG Vs X11? Desktop Environments. 使用x11 和wayland的差异性，以及使用wayland的优劣。 差异性： X与Wayland的主要差异，就是X系统中存在一个X服务器（通常用的是Xorg）。 This patch is not available for the endusers and as i read correctly still proves to be slower than uncomposted x11 (for wayland to be used by comp-gamers this needs to be on-par or better) Though, pen tablet support on KWin/KDE Plasma Wayland would need to be improved too. This is causing lots of visual bugs with my NVIDIA GPU, not to mention the fact that I want to play games on my system. The packet, iirc, is called plasma-wayland-session. But Waypipe is not in the same league as VNC/RDP. Reply reply Brillegeit • The number part in the Ubuntu release names is a date, so "22. Kresimir: I see this parroted a lot, but nobody has any concrete examples for it, so I’m asking: in what way is your Xorg session not secure compared to a Also the KwinFT project, is a window manager for both of the Wayland and X11 windowing systems on Linux. 21 Wayland is ok! If you are on X11 and don’t find Wayland session at the login screen, you probably don’t have it installed. Wayland is an awkward pubescent teenager Annoying mouse cursor misalignment in Plasma Wayland guest on VMWare (but not X11), is there a simple or obvious fix? General Bug Share Sort by: Best. ~60fps under X11 versus 18-22fps under wayland. conf set: However, wayland is much smoother in terms of kwin compositing animations, more responsive and kde effects look better compared to x11 which is sluggish and stuttering once you tried out wayland and go back to x11, you'll know the major difference. Don’t know if I can explain this properly but I will try. The tiny core protocol which necessitates unofficial hacks and extensions so you can have a desktop that actually works (when, ironically, the entire point of Wayland was that it was supposed to have less hacks than X11), the bullshit “security model” (which makes accessible design difficult, also has to be sidestepped so you can have basic It is not often you pick your DE and you have two of everything, one being an X11 and one being Wayland. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at https://discourse. Reply reply IMHO, Wayland vs. For differences between plasma-meta and plasma reference Package group. Pastebin is a website where you can store text online for a set period of time. From that testing with a Lenovo ThinkPad T14s Gen2 with AMD Ryzen 7 PRO 5850U laptop, the GNOME Wayland session led to around 3 Watt lower power consumption than with the same software stack while logging into the X. Kresimir: GNOME is rubbish, and call it junk in the future? That sounds good to me, your opinion. Wayland support for KDE Plasma was delayed until the release of Plasma 5, though previously KWin 4. That said, some applications tend to misbehave with Xwayland, especially games that work via proton/wine. Wayland basically makes the display server and window manager into one single entity called a compositor. 0 Qt Version: 5. A long time before that happens, I need to find a suitable alternative. 0 will release. If your question is about actual color management with ICC stuff and you have a ICC monitor profile file for your display, then you can load that file Adaptive Sync (G-Sync) does work on Plasma Wayland and should default to using it if the monitor feature is detected. What wayland seeks to do is great, but the implementation of it has been bad. A note of gratitude to the Ubuntu developers upvotes · After daily driving both DEs on Wayland for months I've decided to talk about the pros and cons of both on Nvidia GPUs. I noticed higher CPU usage while idle on the kodi GUI comparing x11 to gbm it was only a single experiment, playback of the same file watching CPU usage via top and load average as reported by uptime after playing for 20 min. Not that it's game breaking or anything, looks fine almost everywhere. Phoronix: AMD Radeon Linux Gaming Performance At Parity Between KDE Plasma 6. Graphics rendering and input events can sometimes feel X11 for stability/compatibility, Wayland for features, basically we're currently in the transition phase between x11 and Wayland, it's pretty set and clear that everyone is transitioning to Wayland, but wayland isn't perfect yet, personally i've had very few problems with Wayland especially when using Kde Plasma as the desktop environment, which nobara uses mainly. 0 desktop release along with some point releases for addressing initial fall-out, I've been meaning to run some Plasma 6. Reading the Arch wiki, seems to be that X11 deals better with the mentioned topics (or at least that's what I've understood as most of packages mentioned for both touchscreens and stylus pens are for X11; please correct me if I'm wrong) but also Really? I'm 95% sure I had the issue on both X11 and Wayland, I'll test again tomorrow after my midterm. I still get a slight advantage on X11 over Wayland for minecraft, but it's within 2%. 1 is portrait. Bugs in Plasma X11 just do not have much priority among us, and all automated testing is on Plasma Wayland exclusively. I can't test with other games, unfortunately, because no other games are currently installed as I've Well the title says everything, what are the advantages of wayland over X11 on plasma right now? I'm using the Wayland session and I can't see any real difference besides the latte-dock position, which is kinda clunky due the missing "primary screen" feature. There are still compatibility issues. In System Settings > Startup and Shutdown > Login Screen (SDDM) > Behavior, I'm using auto login with session "System Default" (it means the last used). 1. (0. You just need plasma-wayland-session package. Because Wayland is newer, it was thought for modern computer usage. Using that, I can connect via NoMachine without problems. Alternatively, for a more minimal Plasma installation, install the plasma-desktop package. Firefox I can’t tell if there is a difference between x11 or wayland for gaming (in terms of performance), but if you have a mixed refresh rate monitor setup (one monitor 144hz, secondary monitor 60/75hz) I would recommend using Exploring the transition in Linux's graphical landscape: Dive into the contrasts between Wayland's modern architecture and X11's legacy model. 2 become Wayland instead of the traditional X11, however I still like X11. Old. As far as Proton versions tried on X11 are concerned, with Cyberpunk and Akane, I went through literally all that is available in the Steam client, turned off Steam overlay, and so on. 13 Kernel Version: 6. 10 Gaming Performance As of GDM 42 and NVIDIA driver 510, GDM defaults to Wayland. Firefox got hardware video acceleration on Wayland way before the X11 version did. Missing the option for Plasma Wayland upvote I use a Thinkpad T580 with Intel HD 620 graphics and X11 has issues with games, in which, if I change the resolution to something lower (in proton/wine, and native), I get black flickering bars all over the screen, making the games unplayable. That’s not a strike against Wayland; the reason Nvidia doesn’t work as well on Wayland is because Nvidia have historically been somewhat hostile toward the Wayland project. Add a Comment Applications that directly interface X11 through such libs can have radically different visual styles. If your question is about gamma, that gamma setting is sadly not working on Wayland, it only works on X11. Discover the performance, security, and compatibility implications as Linux Both X11 and Wayland are protocols, the messages that these protocols define can be found as xml here for X11, and here for wayland, but they aren't really that interesting to look at. The Ubuntu community on Reddit Members Online. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. With that exception, in general Wayland will work better on any given GPU than X11. It is possible to use Linux normally only with Wayland, because on legacy X11 you can feel the lack of smoothness of the system and using such a system is simply not pleasant. It only logs into x11. So, you or the developers of distributions can still override the default and have X11 remain the default All these backwards comments "systemd bad, pls bash script distro", "wayland bad, x11 bzt". Within Wayland Session is it possible open one particular app in X11 display? I do have xwayland package installed. No, it works between X11 machines, between X11 and Wayland machines, and between Wayland machines. In X11 it looks like what I would say normal: X11. In /etc/sddm. I was pessimistic. A bit disappointing as i’m sure wayland could make really good use hey guys, I have been switching between x11 and Wayland on my PC and playing DotA, and I noticed that Wayland feels slower? In big team fights FPS will drop to "90" but it feels like 30fps, even though the FPS counter is higher! on x11 it looks like I don't get as many FPS but in big team fights the game doesn't slow down like Wayland does. If you're using an NVIDIA gpu under NVIDIA's notorious proprietary driver, then you should use X11. Wayland is a protocol that can be implemented differently and can have different performance "impacts" depending on how it was implemented. So yeah, it uses the X11 protocol on the game side and unlike with X11, it is capable of straightly feeding it to the card using wayland+drm leases. 01-1 NVIDIA NV-CONTROL X I'm seeing a lot of anti-Wayland posts recently. Upstream KDE has package and setup recommendations to get a fully-featured Plasma session. Native OpenGL itself has I am using Plasma and wanted to bounce back a forth between X11 and Wayland to test X11 vs Wayland. Open comment sort options Plasma 5. The only thing that doesn't The plasma wayland is aware of certain bugs affecting certain nvidia users such as not being able to boot at all. All previous Wayland logins had sent me to unusable desktops, generally with problems with window decorations, despite tweaks to kernel parameters. Also, touchpad gestures do not work on the X11 and the power efficiency is terrible. " The actual backpacks are the various Wayland servers. Can confirm that Debian 12 + Plasma boots up using Wayland as default on Intel 915. And it keeps getting more stable every release. What works and what doesn’t work. That article talks about x11 not getting any exlusive features, only ones that Wayland gets also. I have 3 screens. The problem is that currently in the likes of Discord, MS Teams, Slack, Zoom What are the real benefits as an end-user, when between Wayland and X11? Is the performance of Wayland a lot better as on X11 or do i have other direct benefits? As i have learned today, Wayland has some issues, specially when using KeepassXC, but it seems to be the current default for Manjaro. (At least on KDE) I use a Thinkpad T580 with Intel HD 620 graphics and X11 has issues with games, in which, if I change the resolution to something lower (in proton/wine, and native), I get black flickering bars all over the screen, making the games unplayable. you cant really. No one wants to work kn X11, so it is dying, slowly at first but now speeding up. 5. desktop files or when launching the app from terminal, and the app should try to use the X11 session once you do that (if it doesn't Hello there, Could somebody explain me why Plasma scaling instructions are handled by Unity when I start it from a Wayland session, and not from a X11 session? I mean, on a 4K display: Plasma/X11 with 1. Install the plasma-meta meta-package or the plasma group. I don’t think I have tried KDE/Wayland yet since moving to Leap 15. Arch, Manjaro Linux. e. Stars. Lastly, I also want to say that unlike X11 the issues the Plasma Wayland session exhibits are mostly not structural. sudo pacman -S Popular desktops like GNOME, KDE Plasma, and Enlightenment have added Wayland. The original thread (datedMarch 30) left me scratching my head, because the solution said “what has changed with the new ISOs is that plasma-wayland-session is installed now by default and that gives you the option to choose between Wayland and X11 on the logon screen (lower left corner). But this time, without any changes to kernel parameters or anything else, Wayland worked! Not Wow, i’m experiencing the same exact thing, KDE plasma with wayland is completely nonfunctional with the application menu glitching out and not even opening. AMD is a bit of a mixed bucket graphics support wise atm unfortunately. 0-36-generic (64-bit) Desktop: Graphics Platform: Wayland Yakuake Version: 23. KDE Plasma because it is more leightweight than Gnome, and X11 because it has been around for longer and supports more older hardware than Wayland. You'll want to run this with root privileges too, i. Most known KDE Plasma Wayland I’ve been running Plasma on Wayland since last December and it runs very well for me. Arch Linux - Plasma About Window - Wayland. I'm on sddm version 0. i just wanted basic tiling. I use nobara gnome and when I want to switch between x11 and wayland, I just "log out" and on the login manager screen where I input my password in order to access again there should be a gear icon that it says some stuff about "login on wayland" "login on xorg"; I change between as needed, input the password and done :B What's worse is that it's rarely a wayland vs x11 fanboy debate, in fact x11 barely has any. Such as GTK and Qt. It’s still not standard. Best. How do I switch back to X11? Changing the compositor options don't seem to help much (OpenGL / XRenderer). Asynchronous wait on fence 0000:00:02. This depends way more on which drivers you are willing to install / can install and most importantly on Xorg vs Wayland. 2-1 The GBM EGL external platform library local/egl-wayland 4:1. So how to create a common GUI? Here comes the widget toolkits. This new Fedora release is my first experience with Plasma 6. The default graphic protocol for KDE Nen 6. they create the standard ;-) ). Don’t measure tomorrow’s DE by yesterday DE’s Performance seems better than with X11. Most of the new Plasma 6 distros are keen on shoving Wayland down our throats. At present only Gnome and KDE Plasma within the desktop environments have almost complete support of Wayland. Wayland isn't ready and never will be for everyday usage. Having managed After rebooting, SDDM defaults indeed to X11, which is what I want. cjcox4 The comparison between Wayland and X11 is valid. X11 is dad's old backpack. ) Incidentally, this is why the porting process has taken so long. Three reasons for this removal: Xorg server is deprecated since RHEL 9. When running in wayland mode and launching a wayland or x11 session, there is a gap between sddm and the plasma splashscreen where my grub/kernel initialisation logs show up. I use KDE, and there is KDE X11 and KDE Wayland and both seem to have problem with them. 6 and Plasma 6. Their APUs have mixed experience/quality, 2200G last I heard had quite a few issues, 2400G Posted: Tue Oct 01, 2024 2:35 pm Post subject: Re: Plasma Wayland vs X11 auto login: Progman3K wrote: Hi, If I log out and select Plasma X-11 instead of Wayland, and log back in, then every time I go to the SDDM login menu, Plasma X-11 is set as default. 15. We've made it abundantly clear throughout the last several releases of Fedora KDE that we are generally focused on Plasma Wayland. Personally, I am using X11 with KDE (Plasma). However, my comment was directly related to Workstation 41 and how to enable x11 after a new clean installation. My DE is Plasma. One issue right now for example is that certain games and programs running on Xwayland (older program that cannot use wayland directly in the wayland session) might have tearing for nvidia for example, or older programs trying to record the screen can't see any of the window content (they need to be ported to use pipewire). 5. But, video games should run through XWayland with the Gamescope Wayland compositor. LightDM - Remove "Plasma (wayland)" option in session settings at greeter comment. 27, just in Plasma 6. For older NVIDIA drivers (in between version 470 and 510), GDM has chipset-dependent udev rules to use Xorg rather than Wayland. It is confusing for KDE to use plasma-workspace-x11 and gnome to use gnome-session-xsession to support x11. My guess is that because the Wayland session comes first in the list of sessions to choose from with a new installation, if the user Wayland and X11 Compositor for the KDE Plasma desktop Topics. org relies on a client-server setup. you can use i3-wm to add tiling to raspberry. --https: Hello, Upgraded from Kubuntu 23. For example Opening firefox with my default profile will try to restore 6 windows. Post any KDE Neon-related posts here. Org sessions. 03 definitely kills KDE Wayland for me. New Last time I tried Plasma Wayland on Nvidia was just after the Nvidia drivers started to support GBM and it was really unusable, with windows being a flickery mess and freezes left and right. Obviously, it could change when SteamOS 3. Unless you use something that explicitly gives you control such as Arch Linux, it's your distro's task to transparently switch you over to Wayland 2023 年 KDE 从 X11 切换到 Wayland 的感受文章开始编写于 2023年6月13日 因此如果在这个文章 1个月以外 很可能会有很多很多的变化，本文仅供参考！ sudo apt install plasma-workspace-wayland. KDE Plasma Wayland doesn't have these issues for me. In general, it appears that the render framerate under wayland is about 70% slower for me than under X11- slow enough that it feels like they're lag between typing and text appearing. New. Installation Plasma. Starting a replacement project was deemed to be more Which is better for me, x11 or wayland? Hard to say. 3 different sizes. On mine with AMD graphics and kde plasma I KDE Neon is a linux distribution based on Ubuntu using the KDE Plasma DE. am I crazy or perhaps Wayland is For a while I have been bothered by the mouse speed between X11, Wayland and Windows. some things just wont work cause hyprland doesnt support the protocols for it that kwin does. com is the number one paste tool since 2002. Top. Several distros have announced "removal" of X11, ot Major visual inconsistencies between X11 and Wayland sessions. If you're on older hardware, KDE Plasma and X11 are probably the safer choice. They have it listed in showstoppers and are working to resolve it asap - this one is on plasma devs not nvidia side. Just switched to X11 and everything is working fine. which make the instant change between x11 will there be Wayland added to this distro or is it going stay on xorg / x11? any pros and cons about Wayland? Yeah, Plasma is flirting too much with Wayland. This Running Kubuntu 24. Both: KDE Plasma Version: 5. Quite a few won’t launch without environment variables or at all. It's a magnificent peace of work, and it's so fast in development it regularly has implemented new vulkan features that still has to be published (i. Share Add a Comment. 0 license Activity. 0:kwin Maybe KDE Plasma 6 has a solid Wayland implementation but Plasma 5 didn't, I'd use X11 there. ; We switched from Nvidia-dkms to Nvidia A proper comparison would be X11 (37) <-> Wayland (13) and Xorg (17) <-> Plasma Wayland session (6). The command for this case is journalctl, but use journalctl -xe to have it explain more info (if it can) and go to the end of the logs. forgot you need to comment out the desktop in autostart. I tried KDE Plasma wayland for a month, and even tho the animations and the UI were both pretty smooth, I noticed a terrible gaming experience, much worse than GNOME, where even with 60+ Fps the For X11 the /xsessions would be correct and I think the /wayland-sessions is the other. What in trying to say is that you can install both, and try it yourself. sudo apt update && sudo apt install plasma-workspace-wayland Switch between X11 Describing Wayland and X11 as two types of backpacks is a bit off. Q&A. X. KDE is still somewhat buggy and most other main DEs are still X11-only. 04 this morning on two different laptops. It's not even competing products - wayland is the next version of X11, by the same developers. Gnome is only able to use it because gnome worked around wayland problems thanks to redhat Wayland jsut isn't ready yet, and many applications literally are x11 so they run on x wayland therefore defeating the purpose of using it. 1 Like Last week I posted some benchmarks looking at the laptop battery life implications of GNOME's Wayland vs. Share Sort by: Best. 5) in Plasma to compensate for the increase in speed so these games are all at twice the mouse AFAIK "pgtk" or "pure GTK" means it can display using only the GTK framework, having removed the direct calls to X11 it has had. r/Ubuntu. I am using Plasma and wanted to bounce back a forth between X11 and Wayland to test X11 vs Wayland. 02. I am able to use fractional scaling to match the sizes and placement of everything so moving from screen to screen is fluid and size matched . I usually use X11, but I've been told to use Wayland as my computer seems to freeze quite often. I've decided to give Wayland a go last week after seeing reports of people getting higher FPS on it, but I ran into noticeable input lag compared to X11 (I use KDE Plasma with compositing turned off). Using Plasma Wayland. x11 still gets kwin updates just the same as wayland. 8. 04" means April 2022, so you always have to include the entire release name. 3080Ti on a Dell 4k monitor. I saw wayvnc, but I’m not sure if this is meant to be vnc server or running gnome session (it talks about wlroots which I don’t Plasma X11 on the same machine works without a hitch. X11 is an implementation detail that should be abstracted away from the user. I might have the wrong impression, but I've read about some issues users experience as a result of running Plasma on Wayland and SDDM on X11. Arch Linux - Plasma Desktop - Wayland. If Wayland can run on your system without extensive setup, then you should stick with it. Wayland vs X11: Core Differences. Waiting for some updates :) PS: This did not occur in Plasma 5. 3 so that resizing X11 clients will now appear much more polished than the status quo @omano @AlexBoldt what has changed with the new ISOs is that plasma-wayland-session is installed now by default and that gives you the option to choose between Wayland and X11 on the logon screen (lower left corner). 26. I mainly use hyprland as daily drive but came back time to time to kde (Wayland) I never login into x11 kde. 5 has been released! upvotes Hi, Recently it seems Endeveavour has started using Plasma 6, and it has caused the window system to change from X11 to Wayland. 1 KB. 11 KDE Frameworks Version: 5. It has controller support X11: While X11 has served well for years, its architecture can introduce performance bottlenecks and latency due to the intermediary server-client communication. In one once you enter you Secret Password, it comes back and asks you for it again and again; in the other you get to the screen which then freezes, so you go back I normally start vncserver to have separate GUI session on remote machine, that’s from tigervnc. GTK works equally on X11 or on Wayland, so a pgtk build can display on either, but without it you can't display natively on Wayland (and instead use an X11 emulation layer). when everything works perfectly fine with 'X11'. If I run in x11 mo I had to revert to the previous Nvidia driver 525. I'll have up some Wayland vs X11, and Gnome vs KDE Plasma? This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. I remember when Wayland was a mess and even though all those problems are true and will eventually get fixed once we get more adoption for Wayland, I use Wayland because in my case scenario, X11 is a mess for game performance while streaming and only on Wayland have I been able to stream games while keeping a near perfect game performance. Since not all applications behave the same, we decided to create some examples to help you get started adding games and applications to Sunshine. App Examples#. Only Gnome and Sway have mature implementations, everyone else is a bit behind. In fact I have fixed many things simply by turning off wayland. In wayland everything appears to be slightly smaller, fonts, icons, decorations, etc. I occasionally login to Gnome, which I also have installed. Zircon34 October 21, 2022, 12:28pm 41. 89. Sway is basically 100% i3 compatible (except for general wayland vs x11 things), but its tiling is the same, its IPC is the same and your i3 config should just work. 11 got an experimental Wayland support. It’s been a rough one so far 🙁 Several applications will launch but won’t show a usable GUI. 9. : wayland. I have a 4k hi res laptop screen so the fonts for various menus , text needs adjusting to make it readable for me. There are just a few (Update, July 30 - Now that the FPS cap has been fixed, I am shocked to note a more than 60% drop in performance in Wayland vs X11 using DXVK. Curiously enough, I don’t get the same behaviour with Rocky Linux 9. So, when I turn on my computer every time, I have to manually switch to X11 by logging out, I don’t know if there is any idea which I can switch the First you'll want to get to a terminal, maybe log in with X11, or switch to a TTY with Ctrl+Alt+F2 (Important! Ctrl+Alt+F1 brings you back). People like you are why people have bad preconceptions about the Linux community. KDE Plasma 6 桌面环境默认使用 Wayland，不过依然保留 X11，有需求的用户可以切换回去。 KDE Plasma 6 桌面环境还移植到最新的 Qt 6 开源应用程序框架，初步支持 HDR（高动态范围），改善了对色盲校正过滤器的支持，以及默认情况下采用浮动面板，为用户带 I'm Arch, kernel 6. tea November 5, 2024, 10:42am 4. I know I used to be able to also vnc to existing session by doing x11vnc -usepw -display :1, but it looks like it doesn’t work anymore with wayland. All of them - no developer wants to touch X11 code unless they are getting paid (which Red Hat is paying for their developers, but they will stop soon). Hopefully the tearing protocol gets merged, tho. Wayland may eventually supplant X, but that remains to be seen. Readme License. New features and fixes: Plasma 6 on both the Live environment and the offline installation option – The Live environment runs X11 to ensure support for all hardware and when Plasma is chosen as the installed DE, both offline and online options, Wayland will be the default, but X11 can be chosen as an option in SDDM. I already had automatic logins setup with KDE Wayland and wanted to switch it over so it would always use KDE with X11. We're currently hoping to go Wayland-by-default for Plasma 6 or Plasma 6. 04 on a desktop PC and my ancient HP Pavilion g7 laptop. Currently, is there a way to make LightDM working on Wayland or it could be used only with xorg? Share Add a Comment. This stems from the fact that someone decided that on Wayland when the screen is scaled by a percentage to also scale the mouse with the same percentage. just comment out the i3 statusbar & use lxpanel already there. It works flawlessly on X11, but for whatever reason doesn't work now. Nice, thanks for sharing. It picks audio dynamically at runtime, presumably on Windows, too. I've found some programs that won't run under Wayland. The X11 session will not be going away. 0 Linux gaming performance benchmarks. Here is a screenshot of processes when it is working correctly (that is, after I log into plasma (x11) and then plasma (wayland) and it gets fixed): Screenshot_20241105_140727 1425×1073 66. Jus use your distro defaurl Subreddit dedicated to the the most up-to-date Frameworks and Plasma 5 packages based on the latest Ubuntu LTS. If you have an AMD GPU and use multiple monitors with different refresh rates and one of them has VRR, then use Plasma with Wayland. There is a virtual keyboard button in the bottom left, but no where I can see to select Wayland for the session. Now, Plasma 6 will still have X support, but they plan to drop it in about a year or so. Now on the session manager login screen, I am not able to select between x11 or Wayland. wayland & plasma is pretty much untested. ; Graphics fallback modes are Wayland-friendly now with SimpleDRM enabled Greeting, KDE fanboys, I had using KDE Plasma since 2018, and I had upgrade to KDE Neon 6. Open comment sort options. I am not very knowledgable about window systems and related topics, I’d like to note I just want simplescreenrecorder to work again 🙁 And the A month ago, on impulse, I changed the settings on the SDDM screen to login with Wayland. Can I change back? A lot of things I use don’t work/work incorrectly under Wayland. 4 of Plasma was the first with a Wayland session. may hurt less feelings of other gnome users. 10 to 24. Whatever you all experience now on Plasma 5 is irrelevant. See additional info on the wiki in case you are a nvidia user. My previous results are invalid and I will have to run all the suites again to get a clearer picture of what is going on). The setting can be switched between modes in the native KDE Display settings menu. Pop-up windows will appear in random places – especially when on multi-monitor, but even on a single screen – some UI elements inexplicably turn blurry, and applications temporarily black out, although I can’t reproduce the last bug reliably. Wayland is good but not ready for prime time and that has been for quite some time. News, bugs, and general discussions are all welcome! which should help to ease the transition from X11 to Wayland. Both are Dell Laptops, the 9th gen intel laptop has an Nvidia 1060 You can use either of standard Ubuntu (= Ubuntu with Gnome), Kubuntu (= Ubuntu with KDE Plasma) with X11 or with Wayland. The first thing I noticed was various screen resolution issues. Zircon34 October 21, 2022, 1:00am 29. If I change that to "Plasma (Wayland)", Plasma doesn't boot, it asks for "localhost login" and I don't know what to do. Therefore, the package plasma-workspace-wayland must first be post-installed with TUXEDO OS for Wayland. Plasma. also, plasma is written directly on top of kwin. Unless you don't want hardware acceleration, of course. Both are fully updated. 3 global scale: perfect (but some stuff don’t work like mouse scroll, and some visual It uses X11 and wayland is not not installed but can be installed. Wayland is protocol which says "All backpacks must have two arm straps and a pouch to put things. However some drivers have much less support for Wayland atm. any sort of taskbar wouldnt work for instance. Org-based Plasma 6 on both the Live environment and the offline installation option – The Live environment runs X11 to ensure support for all hardware and when Plasma is chosen as the installed DE, both offline and online options, Wayland will be the default, but X11 can be chosen as an option in SDDM. GNOME Wayland Pros: Better battery life compared to X11 1:1 Touchpad Gestures work great No bugs whatsoever Screen sharing does not impact performance in any way since Mutter uses NVENC Cons:. Additionally there is a BUG in plasma where if you switch back and forward between X11 and Wayland it I didn't notice any difference between x11 and wayland on Gnome. local/egl-gbm 1. 0 and will be dropped in "a future major RHEL release". I do not feel any latency difference between X11 and Wayland on games. 26 Once in a while, there is a booboo, but it recovers in a few seconds, and is seldom enough that I cant be arsed to switch back to X11. 0:kwin_wayland[1362]:18b837c timed out (hint:intel_atomic_commit_ready [i915]) Asynchronous wait on fence 0000:00:02. 08. I hate that crap, it’s not finished (it looks like it will never be finished) and it’s not ready for my typical use cases. GPL-2. Many people online were saying that, by design, Wayland has to run with the compositor enabled, but also nullifying it's input lag downside. I get Wayland has flaws, but personally, it works better than X11 for me. 121 There is a lot going on this year: One of these topics is the possible showdown between X11 and Wayland. The Plasma X11 session does appear in SDDM’s menu, but I’d like it to appear as the default. X11 is an old man, set in his ways, hitting his nurse with a cane whenever she spoonfeeds him asynchronous draw calls. 3 global scale: Unity is tiny (the menu is ok tho) Plasma/Wayland with 1. com with the ZFS community as well. For me, in Wayland, sometimes my laptop freezes completely for 5~10 sec when I open up some program for the first time, I don't know why. You can test if Gnome or KDE Plasma is lighter when you are using Xorg or theyr Wayland equivalents, but thats about it After a system reboot, there’s now an additional option at the bottom right when I login to Fedora, called Plasma X11. The compositor also does a lot more work on wayland than on X11. Traditional X11 forwarding also works in some cases here. LXQt has Wayland now and it isn't provisional or experimental but I don't know how well it works. ) would only update at 60hz, the frame rate of my old second monitor I use Minecraft, for example, is practically unplayable, at least on my setup (Plasma 6 Wayland, GTX 970, 1080p@144 + 1080p@60). And when not working (initial boot into Plasma wayland): 2 1420× Every time I try moving to Wayland I run into one issue or another I am a big gamer, but my primary system is OpenSUSE Tumbleweed with Plasma X11 and all AMD (Ryzen 5900X and Radeon 6900XT) and basic things like screenshot tools (Flameshot, Shutter, ksnip), OBS, Zoom, Bomgar Rep Console, and most games just don't work and those are things I use every day. If you are an NVIDIA user with the All you need to do is sudo apt install plasma-workspace-wayland, and you're good to go! I'd recommend restarting when installed, but for those that didn't know, I hope that helps! I don't use Wayland (I sometimes use X11 over a network which Wayland can't do), but that's a Plasma's wayland compositor, KWin, may work better or be less buggy than Gnome's wayland compositor, Mutter, on your hardware. There are just a few minor things that cause me to prefer X11. but on KDE was even worse. 3 To Improve XWayland Window Resizing KDE developer Vlad Zahorodnii is out with an insightful blog post today on how XWayland window resizing has been enhanced for Plasma 6. Controversial. 1 Like. While implementing Rust in Wayland is years out due to complexity the security advantages of either X11 or The Wayland can be debated but neither is perfect. KDE Plasma 6. Waypipe and SSH X11 forwarding only work for a single app (or multiple apps in a single shell I guess) while VNC/RDP can show the whole screen. Overall on Plasma I would stick to X11 as its generally better for plasma to my knowledge All the information about other spins is great, and I know there are probably many reading this thread for the information it contains. A proper comparison would be X11 (37) <-> Wayland (13) and Xorg (17) <-> Plasma Wayland session (6). Check your journalctl, see if you're getting something like: kwin_wayland[809]: kwin_wayland_drm: Atomic commit failed! Invalid argument kwin_wayland[809]: kwin_wayland_drm: Presentation failed! Wayland is making great improvements. 77-1 NVIDIA drivers utilities (32-bit) local/libvdpau 1. 41. One Wayland bug that, while not a deal breaker, reminds me several times each and every day that the Wayland session still has ways to go is the one that causes Plasma slowdowns after you copy a file and then close either Dolphin or Plasma. I however had to go back to x11 because I couldn't bare any longer this wayland's flickering The plasma desktop can currently still lead to problems like a black screen here under Wayland. Afterwards, you can chose between wayland and x11 at login I’m using plasma desktop with Wayland and the multi monitor multi resolution support is the best. The last person I tried to help simply had the issue go away after time and neither one of us know what the solution was. Had to switch back to x11. 115. Hyprland has a lot more eye candy and is more similar Hi, I have this (maybe?) scaling behavior I can not explain between x11 and wayland. 0 X11 vs. It would only shows 144Hz smoothness when wiggling windows around the screen oddly, but the stuff in the windows themselves (i. GNOME is leading this move. ” Posted: Tue Oct 01, 2024 2:35 pm Post subject: Re: Plasma Wayland vs X11 auto login: Progman3K wrote: Hi, If I log out and select Plasma X-11 instead of Wayland, and log back in, then every time I go to the SDDM login menu, Plasma X-11 is set as default. 27. How to use it? You can set GDK_BACKEND=x11 (or other env variables like XDG_SESSION_TYPE, QT_QPA_PLATFORM) in the . Neither the cursor moves, nothing. So I decided to install i3 on my laptop to test my gaming performance on X11 versus Wayland, because when I run Plasma on X11, if I try to run a graphically demanding game such as Grand Theft Auto V, everything freezes, so I thought a WM without all the bells and whistles of a DE would work better. 530. (Weston, KWin, Mutter, etc. This goes into an The major difference of course is that the Wayland session continually becomes less buggy over time, while the X11 session remains static or becomes more boggy do to diminishing testing and investment in it. I occasionally try Wayland, and it works pretty well. I'm using EndeavourOS. practicalzfs. Sort by: Best. Native OpenGL itself has seen a 15% reduction in performance in Wayland vs X. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. They are popular in Wayland and X11 With Fedora KDE and Kinoite being fully Wayland by default from login to desktop (), it's now time to work toward eliminating our dependency on the Xorg server for Plasma 6. But Wayland lacks the network spread of X11, affecting features like screen recordings. 17-1 EGLStream-based Wayland external platform local/egl-x11 1. Or it might be the other way around. I'm not aware of any real TL/DR: Wayland is working great for me in KDE. 5 Laptop: Graphics Platform: X11 Yakuake Version: 23. The Night Color management in Plasma was a thing on the Wayland session before the X11 session. The security differences between X11 and Wayland seem to be mostly technical: that is to say, yes it's objectively more secure, but I'm not sure that actually means anything significant to the end user. 21. 0-1 NVIDIA XLib and XCB EGL Platform Library local/lib32-nvidia-utils 565. If you have an AMD or Nvidia GPU with two monitors with different refresh rates, but no Freesync or Pretty much all hardware except Nvidia can work better with Wayland than X11. 13 for KDE / Plasma. The X11 session is very smooth for me and I don't have too much screen tearing, I have Overview of the current state of readiness of the Wayland display server protocol for everyday usage, tested on two physical systems with integrated AMD and hybrid Intel + Nvidia graphics using the Plasma 6 desktop Wayland remains a buggy experience on Plasma 5. It picks from Wayland or X11 dynamically at runtime. This video shows you how well this display server protocol performs when I'm using it to play a native Linux game on my I always need to type my password. sudo journalctl -xe since root will have system wide logs Are there some packages I should install in order to get the choice of x11 / wayland ? Thank you for your good advices. 0. conf set: I recently installed Arch + KDE Plasma and the default graphical server that came active was Wayand. Custom properties. is the same. (Update, July 30 - Now that the FPS cap has been fixed, I am shocked to note a more than 60% drop in performance in Wayland vs X11 using DXVK. 5 With Nvidia + Wayland arent good friends yet is the biggest con for Wayland i know of. KDE Plasma should stop making 'Wayland' as default. Wayland doesn't seem quite ready for prime time. Reply reply octoredfox Wayland vs Xorg on Ubuntu 21. GNOME is about the only DE that is stable on Wayland. I end up disabling wayland in favor of X11 on most devices because wayland support for much of the software is poor at best. 3 different resolutions. Users share their experiences, issues, and Wayland is much newer than X11. Almost everyone will acknowledge that wayland is the future, the question is when. kde kde-desktop window-manager wayland-compositor wayland x11-wm Resources. Wayland was started by X11 developers wanting to address the limitations, shortcomings and complexity of X11. Maybe I completely missunderstood the differences between X11 and Wayland, but just two questions out of curiosity: Assumed I want to setup a KDE/Plasma system with strictly Wayland and without any undesirable X11-parts, how to do so? Using EOS Online Installer, selecting xorg-server - (mandatory for Wayland as well as X11, right?) xorg-init - (mandatory Pastebin. The version 5. Based Wayland on Plasma 5 was added later on, is not the default and sure has issues because the DE was developed on X11. You can encounter some real wonky stuff if youre an Nvidia user. Then there are two window managers: Sway and Hyprland. Synergy is one of them, and that keeps me from using Wayland even for the DEs on which it does work. the game, ufo motion test page on Firefox with 144hz enabled, etc. Scaling, font size, icon size etc. 0-6 on Arch linux. Its a mess, and noone will like KDE Plasma becuase of that. Wayland With a few weeks having passed since the KDE Plasma 6. Wayland is stable enough for me with Plasma 2. In this period I have seen Wayland’s performance improve with each update and around A discussion thread about the pros and cons of using X11 or Wayland sessions on Manjaro KDE Plasma desktop environment. There are bugs and features that are specific to each session using the same compositor. 5-3 Nvidia VDPAU library local/libxnvctrl 565. Total package around 1500 which I also got black arch package and python, etc. For whatever reason, when using Wayland I can't drag any apps aside from Firefox to the corners to auto-tile them. After the initial reboot, SDDM defaults to Plasma Wayland, even though I’ve added the configuration stub above. Anything else, I'd definitely run X11 sessions even if With KDE Plasma 6, the Wayland session will be the preferred default option. I'll use it til it wears me out with its glitches. Question Basically, even though I have configured both environments to 125% scaling, the size of elements such as system tray widgets and and the application menu are different sizes between X11 and Wayland and manually scaling them with the grab handles only works for that session. Great job devs! Details: For several years, I've occasionally logged into KDE with Wayland instead of X11. Archived post. So since the best solution would certainly involve breaking the core X11 protocol, it was better to make something from scratch that wouldn't have to carry the old Xorg and X11 cruft, and thus Wayland was born. ryrpfb muiv ugsc vsw eru hpforc rpxyb mocc smowy ertdond